encouraging careful reading

Diogenes teaches beginning expository writing through amplification of familiar proverbs. You may ask questions here about its content, its relationship to grammar or rhetoric, and of course user questions too.

encouraging careful reading

Postby serendipitous » Sun Feb 19, 2017 9:47 pm

Hi! I am planning to begin Diogenes Maxim soon with my 6th grader, having used Aesop & Homer with him, and would like to use the optional reading assignments. He is bright and reads fluently & above grade level, but he also tends to be careless in his work and to skim books. He has already read the Daugherty book (a couple of years ago) so I'd like to try Franklin's Autobiography with him.

My question is: how would you suggest scaffolding him, or encouraging careful reading? We could alternate reading pages aloud; or I could go over new ideas, unusual stuff & so on with him before he reads on his own; or something else.

I am very grateful for this program and appreciate your help!
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Apr 02, 2013 11:07 am

Re: encouraging careful reading

Postby Carolyn » Mon Feb 20, 2017 9:40 am

Some students naturally pay more attention to details, as I am sure you know. Does he pay attention anywhere or is this a global tendency he has, not to be detailed?

In terms of the reading, I would make sure that the material is at or below his reading level, so when you ask for details, at first, it is easy for him to produce the needed details. Sometimes the lack of attention is due to the material being too difficult . (Not necessarily above his ability but perhaps above the level of effort he currently is motivated to put out). Also, pick readings of high interest. If he is competitive, try to compete with him a little on reading something and getting the details right.

The reasons we do the outlining in the earlier stages is precisely to get the students to pay attention to all the details. In literature, it is often the details that are important, the subtle stuff that hangs in the shade, not the blatantly obvious stuff.

If your student is more of a math or science minded person it is quite the opposite. In science we are often looking at the effect that is dominant and considering lesser effects negligible, so we are more so looking for the obvious (not always, but certainly at the K -12 level of science), so he may be conditioned to just thinking about things in a more scientific way.

I would definitely read with him, don’t leave him alone. Taking turns reading aloud is a great idea. After each paragraph or three, stop and note details, perhaps even compete to find the most details.

But, also, if you do try to motivate him to find details, please, also make a strong point of explaining why the details are important. What is it about the stuff that happens on the side that is important? One good place to go for that sort of detailed reading would be mystery books, like Sherlock Holmes or Agatha Christie. The main story line is almost always misleading because someone has reason to hide both his motivations and his actions. Every little observation Holmes makes is of great import.

Let me know if you have other questions.

Posts: 226
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2010 7:26 am

Re: encouraging careful reading

Postby serendipitous » Mon Feb 20, 2017 10:09 pm

Lene, this is so helpful! & helpful across the board, not just with writing -- your insight into the "scientific" way of thinking is, I think, right on target for this child. He is such an analytical, STEM-y little guy. He has produced wonderful, engaging stories & writing with Classical Writing, and definitely has a gift for language, but the scientific way of approaching the world is the way he naturally works.

I'll try the few-paragraph-at-a-time, paired read-and-discuss strategy, & work to implement your idea of helping him see why the particular details are important if we want to understand what we read. I can see that making this explicit would really help him.

He also has thoroughly enjoyed the little bit of Sherlock Holmes we did aloud, so I will work to get Sherlock going again. It seems hard to fit in, but I like Sherlock a great deal myself; it would be a bit of a treat.

Thank you for sharing your time, insight, and experience. I'm so grateful for this help in teaching my little one!
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Apr 02, 2013 11:07 am

Return to Book III: Diogenes: MAXIM -- Beginning Expository Writing

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest